Case Law Updates

Federal Court (Full Court). One of the judges of the Full Court had appeared as the Commonwealth Director of Public Prosecutions in a conviction appeal on a point of law involving the non-citizen in question. The non-citizen's representative applied for that judge to recuse himself from hearing the appeal from an FCA decision dismissing a judicial review application.

Federal Court. Can it be said that, if the Tribunal's "failure to inquire was unreasonable, then for there to be a jurisdictional error the failure must be material in the sense that without the failure there would have been a realistic possibility of a different outcome on the review"? Is non-compliance by the Tribunal with s 424A(1) necessarily material to the outcome?

Federal Court. In considering whether an applicant for visa subclass 309 (partner) was a de facto partner of the visa sponsor, was the Tribunal allowed to consider the best interests of the affected children or related issues or "any hardship that might be occasioned by refusal of the visa, be that to the visa applicant, the sponsor, or their children"?

Federal Court. In circumstances where a judicial review applicant previously brought judicial review proceedings against the same administrative decision in question, is the question of whether the subsequent application is prevented by the principles of res judicata or Anshun estoppel determined by treating judicial review as a whole as the relevant "cause of action"? Was the Tribunal entitled to consider an ITOA and its conclusion for the purpose of s 501CA(4)? Was Tribunal required to be satisfied of Art 1C of the Convention?

Federal Court. In order for an error (or errors) in the form of legal unreasonableness in a decision-making process to be labelled "jurisdictional", is it necessary for the materiality of the error to be established as a separate, additional element? Does Makasa apply to s 501(1)? In exercising the power under s 501A(2) to override a decision of the Tribunal, can the Minister rely on matters that were known to him at the time of the Tribunal hearing but not put by him (or on his behalf) to the Tribunal?

Federal Court. Can it be said that, in forming a view, for the purposes of r 1.15AA(1)(e) of the Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth), "as to whether the assistance cannot reasonably be (a) provided by any other relative of the resident (being a relative who is an Australian citizen, an Australian permanent resident or an eligible New Zealand citizen), or (b) obtained from welfare, hospital, nursing or community services in Australia, it is necessary for the Tribunal to have regard to the nature and extent of the relevant person’s need for direct assistance in attending to the practical aspects of daily life"?

Federal Court. Was the Tribunal allowed to 'net off’ or offset against one another the various factors that it took into account when considering under cl 14.5 of Direction 79 the extent of impediments that the Applicant may face if removed from Australia?

Federal Court. Are the words "before the Minister" in s 473DC(1)(a) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) confined to information that was before the Minister in an applicant's application? Or is information "before the Minister" so long as a delegate has "actual awareness" of the information, whether or not it formed part of the application?

Federal Court. Does the IAA need to "hold an interview merely because it was minded to reach a different credibility finding from a delegate"? Are the ratio of the FCAFC's decision in DPI17 and the High Court's decision in ABT17 "confined to an instance in which the delegate’s overturned finding had been overtly and significantly based on an express assessment by the delegate of the applicant’s demeanour"?

Federal Court. In MZAPC, the High Court held that an error in the form of non-compliance with the condition that the "ultimate decision" that is made lie within the bounds of reasonableness is material by definition and thus jurisdictional. Does that ruling apply to legal unreasonableness in the decision-making process?